Why does an attic need ventilation?
A ventilated attic keeps the roof deck close to the outdoor temperature and lets moisture leave, so the snow above the deck melts evenly and the wood stays dry. Without ventilation, heat and humidity from the house collect under the roof and cause the problems the state's ice-dam guidance describes.
Air moves from the soffit vents, across the underside of the deck, and out at the ridge. The movement carries away the moisture that rises from the living space through the ceiling, and it keeps the deck cold.
Should I insulate my attic or ventilate it first?
The state and UMass name insulation, air sealing and ventilation together as the cure, so the work is planned as a single job. Air sealing comes first in practice, because warm, moist air leaking through gaps undoes both insulation and ventilation.
Insulation without air sealing lets warm, moist air reach the cold deck through the gaps, and the moisture condenses where the insulation cannot reach it. Ventilation without insulation lets heat escape from the ceiling into the attic, which keeps the deck warm.
Can ventilation alone stop ice dams?
Not on its own. UMass says proper insulation and roof ventilation together can stop ice dams from forming altogether, and the state's handout names air sealing and keeping the roof close to outdoor temperature as the target. Ventilation is one part of a three-part fix.
Ventilation lowers the temperature of the deck, which reduces the melting that starts the dam. It does not stop heat leaking from the living space if the ceiling is open, so a ventilation-only job can leave the warm spots in place.
What does the Department of Energy field test tell a homeowner?
The Department of Energy's Building America field tests show that ventilation and moisture control affect how long a roof deck and its shingles last. Unvented assemblies under high interior humidity were compared with top-vented ones, and the vented ones handled moisture better.
The tests were designed for climate-specific research, and this site uses them only for the general principle. They support the argument that moisture from the house has to leave the attic, and that a roof assembly with no path for it is more likely to see wood-moisture problems over time.
What should I check after the work is done?
Check the attic on a cold morning for frost on the deck, and watch the eave on the next thaw for ice. Keep a note of the date, the weather and what you saw, because that record is the clearest test of the work.
If frost appears on the deck in the same places as before, the air sealing or the vent path needs another look. If the eave still forms ice in the same spot, the attic side of the problem has not been addressed there, and it should go back to the technician with the note.